Two members down nine months apart, and the volume still built whole
A four-bay Synology in a joinery works had flagged bad sectors on one member back in January, and the warning emails had been switched off rather than answered. When a second member stopped, the unit came back reporting a failed volume, and somebody had already written the plan on the lid in marker pen: fit a new disk, leave it to rebuild. That was the single thing we would not do. Both failed members took new head stacks, all four were imaged, and the RAID 5 volume was built from the images rather than from the disks.